More in Estimates and Choosing a Shop →
You picked up your car and something is off. The paint looks slightly different in certain light. A panel gap is wider than it should be. A trim piece is loose. It happens sometimes, even at shops that care about their work. What matters is catching it quickly and handling it the right way.
Most body shop repair problems are fixable. Here's how to work through it.
Don't drive away if something looks wrong at pickup
The moment you pick up your car is the best time to say something. Walk the entire vehicle before you pay the final balance or sign the release form. Look at the repaired area in daylight. Check the paint from different angles. Look at the gaps between panels. Open and close any door that was worked on.
If something looks off right there, point it out. A professional shop expects customers to inspect the finished work. A good shop owner would rather hear about a concern in the parking lot than get a call three days later.
Take photos before you leave
Even if you mention a concern out loud, take photos on your phone before you drive away. Date-stamped photos give you a clear record of what you saw and when. Get close-ups of the paint, the panel gaps, any trim or clips you have questions about.
This documentation protects you and gives the shop something specific to work from. A photo of the repaired door next to the untouched door is more useful in a conversation than a description alone.
Talk to the shop owner or manager directly
Your first move is a direct conversation. Call the shop or go back in and explain exactly what you are seeing. Be specific. Saying the paint on the rear quarter panel looks a shade lighter than the front door in direct sunlight is useful. Saying it doesn't look right is harder to address.
Most body shop concerns fall into a handful of categories: a paint blend that did not come out perfectly, a trim clip that did not get reinstalled, or a panel alignment that is slightly off. These are fixable things, usually correctable in a follow-up appointment. Start with the direct call before anything else.
Know what your warranty covers
Ask for your warranty in writing if you did not receive one at pickup. California requires auto body shops to provide a written warranty on parts and labor. Quality shops warrant their workmanship for as long as you own the vehicle, and parts carry the manufacturer warranty term for that part.
If the issue falls under the warranty, bring that up in your conversation. The shop is obligated to correct warranted work at no charge. See our full breakdown in what a body shop warranty actually covers.
When to contact the California Bureau of Automotive Repair
If you have talked to the shop directly and the problem is going nowhere, the California Bureau of Automotive Repair (BAR) is your next step. The BAR licenses all auto body shops in California and handles consumer complaints. File at bar.ca.gov.
Filing a BAR complaint is free. An investigator contacts the shop and reviews the situation. Most shops resolve disputes quickly once a BAR case is open because their license depends on their record with the agency.
When your insurance company is part of the picture
If the repair was paid through a collision insurance claim, your insurer approved the scope of work. If the shop did not complete the approved work correctly, your adjuster has standing to follow up. Call them, describe the specific issue, and ask them to contact the shop. Your insurer wants the job completed right as much as you do.
What you should expect from a family-owned shop
We are family owned and operated. When you pick up your car from Mashore Autobody in Brentwood, we walk through the repair with you before you leave. We want you to look at it, ask questions, and tell us if anything is off while you are still here.
Our standard is pre-accident condition, often better than before. If something is not meeting that standard, we fix it. That is what unmatched quality and unrivaled service means in practice, not just on a sign.
If you are shopping for a shop and want to know what to look for before you commit, read how to choose a body shop you can trust and our list of questions to ask before you hand over your keys. Call 925-516-1930 or stop in for a free estimate.
Frequently asked questions
What if the shop says the repair looks fine but I still disagree?
Take photos and document your specific concern in writing. You can get a second opinion from another shop with a written assessment. If the issue is within warranty scope, the shop is legally obligated to address it. If you are still not getting anywhere, file a complaint with the California Bureau of Automotive Repair at bar.ca.gov. An investigator will review the case at no cost to you.
How long do I have to report a problem after picking up my car?
Check your written warranty for the specific terms. Most workmanship warranties run for as long as you own the vehicle. For manufacturer-warranty parts, the term varies by the part. Report the problem as soon as you notice it. Do not wait to see if it works itself out.
Does the warranty cover a paint color difference?
Paint matching is part of the workmanship. If the repaired panel looks noticeably different from the adjacent panels in standard lighting conditions and the shop used the correct color code, this is a workmanship issue the warranty should cover. A subtle difference right at the blend edge is common and usually within spec. A visible difference from a normal viewing distance is worth raising.
Can I get a second opinion from a different body shop?
Yes. You can take your car to another shop for an independent assessment of the repair quality. That shop's written opinion can support your case if you need to escalate to the California Bureau of Automotive Repair or to your insurance adjuster.
What is the California Bureau of Automotive Repair and how do I file a complaint?
The BAR is the state agency that licenses and oversees all auto repair shops in California. They handle consumer complaints about repair quality, disputes, and work that does not meet the agreed-upon scope. File at bar.ca.gov. The process is free, and an investigator contacts the shop and reviews the issue on your behalf.
Next step
Call (925) 516-1930 or stop by 44 Sycamore Ave, Suite A in Brentwood. Estimates are free. Read about our collision repair, how we work, or get directions and hours. We serve Brentwood, Oakley, Antioch, Discovery Bay and Byron.